CFA Level II Exam Study Progress

Last year I passed the CFA Level I exam with about 150 hours of study, working directly from the books provided by the CFA Institute. This year I am attempting to repeat the same process with the CFA Level II exam. It’s pretty well known that Level II is the most difficult of the three CFA exams. From my discussions with people who have have earned their CFA charters, it seems that very few of them passed Level II on their first try.

CFA Level II Exam Format

The format of Level II is similar to Level I in that all the questions are multiple-choice with three answer choices. However, for Level II there are only 120 questions total, compared to 240 questions for Level I. Since the exam is 6 hours long, this works out to three minutes per question. Many of the questions are qualitative concepts and can be solved in under a minute, so there’s really no time pressure. However, the quantitative calculation-based questions tend to be much more difficult than those found on Level I; some require extensive reworking of financial statements to get to the answer.

The questions in Level II are grouped into “item sets”. An item set means there is a short case study followed by six questions about a particular topic. For example, there may be a case study of an analyst doing a valuation of a common stock, with included financial statements and other metrics. The six questions in the item set will all relate to the information provided by the case study.

My out-of-pocket cost for Level II was just $830, as compared to $1,215 for Level I. For Level I there was an additional fee to join the CFA program.

CFA Level II Study Plan

Over the past few months I’ve slowly worked my way through the six books provided by CFA Institute. Some of the material expands upon concepts introduced in Level I, and some if it is brand new. I’ve tried to read every chapter and do as many of the end-of-chapters exercises as I could; however, there are some sections that are just too incomprehensible and I skimmed over them. In particular, I found the chapters related to derivatives and statistical methods almost impossible to get through. There is also a very opaque section on pricing bonds with embedded options that I don’t even want to look at.

However, for the most part, I’ve enjoyed reading the CFA books. I’m a career changer into finance and I’m interested in the material for its own sake. In particular, I liked the books about Corporate Finance and Equities. The Equities book spends extensive time discussing the concept of “economic profit”, which is profit that a business earns over and above its cost of capital. The concept of “net income” as widely reported in the financial press is an accounting measure that may be vastly different from economic reality; the concepts of free cash flow, economic profit, and residual income are more closely tied to the true profit-generating potential of a business.

As of now, I’ve taken two full-length practice exams. I’m a little disappointed to say that I scored only about 50% correct on each. According to the internet, the supposed ‘minimum passing score’ is around 70% correct; that would mean 84 correct answers out of 120 questions.  So I clearly have room for improvement. However, in reviewing the exams it was clear that there were many questions for which I simply didn’t know the correct formula. For these types of questions, you either know it or you don’t; if you know the formula then you can calculate the correct answer, and if you don’t know the formula then you have to guess.

In passing Level I last year, I found that learning much of the material was amenable to brute-force memorization. I created a huge set of flash cards that included all of the formulas and concepts I needed to memorize – how to calculate financial ratios, what happens to them when conditions change, what are the key underlying concepts, etc. During the last few weeks before the exam I took these flash cards everywhere, read and reread them, and asked a work friend to quiz me during lunch. They were very helpful in passing the exam.

To some extent, I think this flash-card memorization approach works for Level II as well. Some formulas just need to memorized. However, some of the more difficult Level II material really requires a deep understanding of financial concepts and the ability to apply them in the specific context of a particular case study. On some of my flash cards I’ve had to write out whole paragraphs, and it’s better to understand a concept than to just memorize a paragraph. On the other hand, if you reread a paragraph enough times you do tend to eventually understand it.

There is another key study tip that I used last year. For the official Mock Exam provided by the CFA institute, I made sure I understood the correct approach to solving every single question. The official Mock Exam is the best source of questions available and it’s the most representative of the actual exam. Why wouldn’t you understand every single question? You don’t know what questions will appear on the actual exam, but you know the CFA Institute has provided guidelines in the form of the Learning Outcome Statements and Mock Exam questions, so you should be sure to understand them. Accordingly, I’ve been thoroughly reviewing the Level II Mock Exam and created a large set of notes and flash cards.

Concluding Thoughts

Right now the CFA Level II exam is just over two weeks away. Although I am behind in my study progress compared to last year, I intend to put in serious hours to get myself up to the 70% correct level. It’s likely that I will take another practice exam, review my notes, and do more end-of-chapter exercises from the CFA books.

 

 

 

CFA Level I Exam Results: Passed!

Yesterday I received the good news that I passed the CFA Level I exam. The exam is graded pass/fail, but they give you a breakdown of your % correct by topic area:

CFA Level I Results

Supposedly the minimum passing score (“MPS”) is about 70% correct, so the weighted average of the categories above must have exceeded the MPS. Looking back through my posts about my study strategy, I see that I took the official practice test three weeks before the exam and only got 58% correct. After that, I made a concerted effort to thoroughly understand all of the questions I had missed; I read through the explanations, made over 100 flash cards, and redid the problems multiple times. Somehow that earned me enough extra points to pass the exam.

Overall I spent about 150 hours studing over the course of 4 months. I think that, just like the GMAT, the absolute best source of sample problems is from the test makers themselves.

Here’s my previous posts about studying for the CFA Level I:

Taking the CFA Level I Exam (March 6th)

CFA Level I Progress (May 12th)

CFA Level I Test Day Experience  (June 22nd)

 

CFA Level I Test Day Experience

After four months of hard work and studying for about 10-15 hours per week, I finally took the CFA Level I Exam on June 2nd. I won’t actually find out whether I passed or not until July 24 (about 7 weeks after the test).

Just to recap, here are some quick facts about the test: The Level I CFA Exam consists of two 3-hour sessions, the first from 9am-12pm and the second from 2pm-5pm. Each session is comprised of 120 multiple choice questions, for an overall total of 240 questions. The questions have three answer choices each, and the exam uses pencil-and-paper and a scantron answer form. Two specific models of financial calculator are allowed – I used the HP BAII Plus.

The CFA Institute changes the minimum passing score each year, but it seems to be around 70%. Every question is weighted equally, so you need to aim for 168 correct answers to be confident of passing. This is different from the GMAT, which is an adaptive test in which questions can be weighted differently depending on their difficulty level.

The exam was given in a huge conference room at the Anaheim convention center. I estimated there were about 1,000 test takers in the room, but that included all three CFA exam levels. Although the exam didn’t formally start until 9am, they required everyone to be sitting quietly in their chairs by 8:30. There was a lot of sitting around while the staff did various administrative things before and after the actual exam times.

I can’t discuss the content of the exam, as the CFA Institute has very strict non-disclosure rules. I can say that, as I expected, the most accurate practice test is the full-length ‘mock exam’ that is provided by the CFA Institute. The mock exam is 240 retired actual CFA Level I questions. If you plan on taking the CFA exam, I’d recommend a thorough understanding of every single one of the 240 practice questions. I made a big pack of flash cards (over 100 in total) of formulas to memorize, and that turned out to be very helpful. Some of the questions simply required knowledge of a specific formula – if you knew the formula, you could plug in the numbers and get the question right; if you didn’t, you had to guess.

Since the CFA exam is pencil-and-paper, you can skip questions and come back to them later. Within each 120-question section, there were probably 10-15 questions that I was unsure about; I passed them over with the intention of coming back to them at the end. However, when I got to the end of the section, I actually didn’t have much time for the questions I had skipped; I wound up just choosing my first instinct. The fact that you can skip questions is a difference between the CFA exam and the GMAT. Since the GMAT is computerized, you have to answer each question before you proceed to the next one, and you can’t go back and change your answers. On the CFA exam, you can change an answer choice if you have the time to carefully erase the previous one.

There was a two-hour break from 12-2 during which we could get lunch. However, we had to be back in our seats by 1:30, and there were huge lines for all the fast food establishments on site. So the break felt a little rushed. I managed to get a tall Starbucks coffee and the 260 mg of caffeine helped me stay focused during the afternoon session. Still, I was fading out towards the end due to tiredness and mental fatigue.

Overall, the exam is definitely tougher than the GMAT, mostly due to the sheer volume of material and the 6-hour length. Honestly, after taking the CFA exam, the 3-hour time of the GMAT seems like a cakewalk.

Regarding exam prep, I prepared using 1) The CFA books themselves 2) The short 60-question sample exams provided by CFA Institute 3) The full-length mock exam from the CFA Institute and 4) A single Schweser full-length exam that I purchased for $50. I didn’t take the Schweser full-length class, and I didn’t buy the Schweser notes. After talking to other people on exam day, it seemed like no one besides me had prepared from the actual CFA books. Almost everybody had taken a Schweser course and many people had the Schweser notes. I guess it remains to be seen what is more effective.

I wish the CFA Institute gave the exam results right away. However, the results won’t be available until July 24th. If you pass, you simply get a “pass” grade without knowing how much you passed by; if you don’t pass, they give you a general ranking of how close you came. I am looking forward to seeing how I did, and in the meantime will resume tutoring and writing about the GMAT.

Author:

 

CFA Level I Exam Progress

It’s now exactly three weeks until the CFA Level I exam, so I thought I’d post about my progress. I’ve now managed to read through most of the material, which consists of 6 very thick books of about 500 pages each. I skipped a few chapters that I didn’t think were important, and I skipped over the entire sixth book (Derivatives/ Alternative Investments.) This topic is only a very small portion of the exam (less than 10 questions out of 240) and I have to manage my time carefully, so I didn’t think there was a good ROI on reading this book.

As far as practice exams go, the CFA Institute gives you two resources:
1) One full-length, 240-question, six-hour mock exam written by the Institute itself, which is supposed to accurately represent the content of the real exam. This is provided as a PDF that you print out and answer with pencil-and-paper (like the real exam).

2) Two 2-hour, 60-question sample exams, which appear to be written by a third-party test prep provider, and are taken through a web browser. Annoyingly, these exams cost an extra $40 each.

This weekend I took the full-length mock exam. The result was a somewhat disappointing 58% correct. Although the CFA Institute doesn’t provide the actual percentage you need to pass the exam, the internet says that the passing score is about 70-75% correct. To be on the safe side, I am aiming to get 75% correct, which would be 180 out of the 240 questions. Based on my 58% correct result from the mock exam, I only answered 140 questions correct, so I need to improve by 40 more questions. I’m glad I took the exam this weekend since I have another three weeks to study and improve. I feel much better prepared after reviewing the answers from the mock exam.

After reviewing the answers, I came to this conclusion: many of the questions I had missed required memorizing very specific formulas or very specific facts. For example, they expect you to memorize how to calculate over 20 different financial ratios, or know the finer points of accounting differences between US GAAP and IFRS. I think this level of detail is what makes the exam so difficult – there’s just an enormous amount of material that needs to be memorized. In real life, I would just dump the calculations into Excel; but of course the exam would be easy in that case.

On the plus side, a good portion of the questions are qualitative  and can be answered correctly if you have a solid grasp of  finance fundamentals; I did reasonably well on these types of questions.

At this point I would estimate that I’ve studied for about 150 hours, and I’ve spent $1,255. I’m glad I took the practice exam this weekend; I’ve spent the past week reviewing it and I’ve now memorized another 50 formulas :-) I may wind up spending another $49 and purchasing a full-length mock exam from Schweiser. There’s certainly no guarantee at this point that I will pass, but I’m going to put in the work over the next few weeks and do my best.

Author: Matt Kirisits.

Taking the CFA Level I Exam, June 2012

I’ve been interested in beginning the CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst) program for some time, and last month I finally signed up for the June 2nd test day. The cost of registering for the exam was $1215, which  included a required set of six books published by the CFA Institute. Additionally, I bought a financial calculator for $50 and will have to pay $40 apiece for two sample exams. I figure that’s enough of an expense already, so I’m opting out of purchasing any additional test-prep materials and instead studying on my own.

It’s interesting to be back in the position of studying for a standardized test. For the Level I exam, the CFA Institute recommends a total of 300 (!) hours of study time over the course of six months. That’s considerably more than a typical GMAT course of study, which runs around 100 hours. Once I received the CFA books, it made sense why they recommend so much prep time: there is a lot of material. There’s a total of six books and they’re 500-700 pages each.

I began studying in early February, so I’m actually aiming to pass the exam with an overall prep time of only four months. However, I figure I have a couple advantages. First of all, I already have an MBA, so I’ve learned some of the CFA material already at the graduate level. Secondly, a big part of the exam (20 to 50 percent) is related to financial statement analysis, and I have a decent understanding of this topic already. So I hope that I’ll be able get through the material on time.

That being said, there’s no doubt this is a very difficult exam, and there’s obviously no guarantee I will pass. Unlike the GMAT, the CFA exam is not scored – rather, it’s Pass/ No Pass. The pass rate as of June 2011 was only 38%.

Study Strategy For The CFA Level I

My general study strategy for Level I is as follows. For each chapter in the books, I begin by reading the “Learning Outcome Statement” in the beginning, which tells you what the testmakers expect you to know after reading the chapter. I then read the chapter one time and take very detailed notes. I try to make my notes detailed enough so I can re-learn the material by reviewing my notes instead of re-reading the books. I figure that I’m forced to follow this strategy because there’s simply too much material to keep re-reading the books. If I had to review the books themselves, I would never get through all the material.

The potential flaw in this strategy is that I am ‘flying in the dark’ – I don’t really know what is likely to appear on the exam and what is not. I have to use my judgment as to what to take notes on, and what to skip – it’s sort of like doing Reading Comprehension passages on the GMAT. :) However, each chapter in the CFA books does have the “Learning Outcome Statement” which provides guidance on what the testmakers consider important. The CFA Institute also published a general breakdown of the topic weighting on the exam.

Otherwise, I am trying to maximize the value of the official practice questions. Most of the chapters in the books have 20-40 review questions at the end, and I’m trying to treat these questions like the real exam. I’m only doing these problem sets when I feel like I understand the material and can fully focus on them. When I’m reviewing my results, I am keeping an error log and noting both the questions I missed, and the questions on which I guessed correctly. I’m also timing myself to get a general sense of how long the questions take.

Apart from the end-of-chapter problem sets, the CFA Institute provides two 2-hour “Sample Exams”, which unfortunately cost another $40 apiece. I am waiting on these until I get through all the material. There’s also a single full-length “Mock Exam” which is six hours long, just like the actual exam. I will probably take that in early May, a month before test day.

Realistic Study Planning

One thing I’ve found to be very helpful in my studying is to plan around my own lack of discipline. I have a full-time job, and I’ve discovered that I rarely have the energy or discipline to study after work. Instead, the best time for me to study (on weekdays) is in the morning, before I start work. On weekends, I try to put in a solid 2 hours in the morning, and then more time when I am free later in the day. Overall, this adds up to about 10 hours per week. Realistically, I think this about all I can handle while working my full-time job and tutoring the GMAT.

As of this writing, I’m midway through the second CFA book, Economics. I find this book to be completely uninteresting and Economics is supposedly just 10% of the exam, so I’m just trying to plow through it as fast as I can. I’m actually looking forward to the Financial Reporting and Valuation books that are coming up.

Author: .